CHARLESTON, W.Va. – Today, West Virginia Attorney General JB McCuskey filed lawsuits in New Jersey and Washington, D.C. challenging rules that bar West Virginia solar energy producers from selling solar energy credits in those markets. The rules raise electric bills for West Virginians, and cost New Jersey and D.C. customers too.
The filings follow a lawsuit filed by the Attorney General in Pennsylvania in September, challenging similar restrictions. West Virginia, Pennsylvania, New Jersey and D.C. all belong to PJM Interconnection, which operates the grid across 13 states and the District of Columbia. Electricity generated in any of these states can serve customers in another – except solar.
Renewable energy laws in Pennsylvania, New Jersey, and D.C. mandate electric suppliers obtain a certain percentage of their energy each year from renewable energy sources. To fulfill that requirement, electricity suppliers can buy renewable energy credits. But New Jersey and D.C., along with Pennsylvania, treat solar energy credits differently. They have laws that say solar credits can only be purchased from producers located within their respective borders. The explicit geographic restrictions are textbook Commerce Clause violations, discriminating against out-of-state industry.
“The geographic restrictions serve no legitimate environmental or governmental purpose and as a result, the compliance costs in those states have skyrocketed while West Virginia solar energy producers are left facing unconstitutional trade barriers. We should all be working toward a more efficient and reliable system, but rules like these stand in the way of progress, and ultimately all households and businesses pay the price,” Attorney General McCuskey said.
Washington D.C. has among the highest energy credit prices in the country, averaging $407 per credit. Additionally, D.C. suppliers paid more than $50 million in compliance penalties from 2018 through 2025 for credits they could not obtain. In New Jersey, credits trade up to $200 each, while the voluntary markets used by West Virginia solar producers average between $2 and $8. As a result of these laws, West Virginia solar generators miss out on hundreds of millions of dollars in revenue. Those costs flow through to ratepayers.
West Virginia regulated utilities are authorized to build solar generation and sell its output and credits, and the proceeds are credited back to customers. Because West Virginia credits are barred from these markets, West Virginia rate payers also lose.
The lawsuits are asking the courts to strike down the geographic restrictions and open the markets to bring down costs for consumers on all sides.
